The resort I originally planned on staying was apparently severely damaged along with most of A1A. I booked a hotel on the west coast in Clearwater but unfortunately never got to use it. Seems the roads between Dillon, SC (South of the Border) and Lumberton, NC were completely impassable. I tried Monday night and again Tuesday morning but they were taking people off the southbound I-95 and putting them right back on the northbound side at Exit 31.
I ended up canceling my reservation (fortunately without any penalties) and instead I'm visiting friends in Virginia and Pennsylvania on this trip. Worst part of Monday night was not being able to find a working hotel with vacancies until I backtracked all the way to Fayetteville... and that hotel was a DUMP (but at least it had a vacancy).